I'd be VERY careful. It depends on the amp. If your amp has no standby switch, then do not use a 5U4 or 5Y3. They are directly heated and will slam your tubes with B+ before they are warmed up.
A 5AR4/GZ34 is indirectly heated, which means it has a built-in time delay befoe it puts out B+ to the plates of the other tubes.
You can substitute a 5V4 safely for a 5AR4 if you want a little more sag. I run one in my JMI AC30. The 5V4 is designed like the 5AR4, but with lower voltage and less current output.
If you do have a standby switch, Steve is right about the current draw on the 5U4. The problem with a 5Y3 is that it only puts out 125 mA of current vs. 225mA for a 5AR4 and 175mA for a 5V4 at normal RMS voltages). For some amps 125 mA is not enough to run everything. So, again, it depends on the amp. A 5Y3 usually will be enough for a two channel amp running a pair of 6V6s or EL84s. But I wouldn't put a 5Y3 in a two channel amp that runs a pair of 6L6s or EL34s unless the manufacturer says it's OK.
"Your mind is on vacation, but your mouth is working overtime" - Mose Allison
Vox: 65 AC30 SRT, 64 AC50 MkII, 64 AC4, 65 tube Cambridge, 66 tube Cambridge, 66 tube Berkeley, 65 tube Pathfinder, Pathfinder 10, V807 echo reverb; 61 Klemt Echolette B40 combo, 64 Fender BF Deluxe Reverb, 67 Fender BF Super Reverb, 68 Fender SF Bandmaster Reverb, 74 SF Vibrolux Reverb, 64 Silvertone 1484, Laub Unique 26R, GK 206ML/E, Leslie 145, Leslie 860...